Skip to Main Content

Literature Reviews and Field Statements

This guide is designed to support Schar PhD students conducting research for their field statements and literature reviews. It may also be useful for thesis writers.

What is a literature review?

The literature refers to the published books and articles that contain contributions to an ongoing conversation among scholars. A conversation might be large (on the nature of liberty); it might be tightly focused (on the figure of the highwayman in Locke’s Second Treatise).

A literature review is an analysis of the ongoing conversation on a topic, question, or issue. A strong literature review organizes existing contributions to a conversation into categories or “threads.” For each category or thread, a literature review might highlight particularly interesting books or articles, then briefly cite or mention other instances. It is possible to have a category populated by just one book or article. A literature review typically serves to identify an opportunity or opportunities for new research on a topic.

A literature review is NOT a summary of everything said on a topic; nor is it a chronological account of publications on a topic.

A literature review answers questions such as:

  • What is the current state of the literature/research on your topic?
  • What are the major contributions to the study of your topic? What do they say?
  • What are the “threads,” themes, or categories in the conversation about your topic? Do you find any of these particularly valuable? Why?
  • What are the major disagreements or debates on this topic? Are there any areas of consensus?
  • Do you see anything missing or otherwise problematic in the literature?