Skip to Main Content
It looks like you're using Internet Explorer 11 or older. This website works best with modern browsers such as the latest versions of Chrome, Firefox, Safari, and Edge. If you continue with this browser, you may see unexpected results.

Systematic Reviews

Searching

PRISMA for Searching

The PRISMA extension for searching (PRISMA-S) was published in 2021. The checklist includes 16 reporting items, each of which is detailed with exemplar reporting and Rationale.  This checklist guides the researcher in how to document the search process in a systematic review.

Here is an example of keyword and MeSH search concepts for a PICO question.

PICO: Do e-cigarettes help current smokers, who have tried to quit before, finally succeed  in quitting?

 

MeSH Terms

"Smoking Cessation/methods"[Mesh]

OR

“Tobacco Use Cessation” [Mesh]

OR

"Tobacco Use Cessation Products"[Mesh]

Keywords (Title/Abstract)

“Smoking cessation” [TI/AB] OR

 “Nicotine Replacement” [TI/AB] OR

 “Quit* Smoking”[TI/AB] OR

 “Stop* Smoking” [TI/AB]

AND

AND

MeSH Terms

Keywords

“quit attempt*” [TI/AB]

AND

AND

MeSH Terms

“Electronic Nicotine Delivery Systems” [Mesh]

Keywords

E-cigarette*[TI/AB] OR

“electronic cigarette*”[TI/AB]  OR

Vape [TI/AB]  OR

Vaping[TI/AB]

Search using keywords

  • Use "" for phrase searching: "smoking cessation"
  • Use * for truncation: protect* retrieves protect, protects, protection, protecting

“Smoking cessation”[Title/Abstract] OR “Nicotine Replacement”[Title/Abstract] OR “Nicotine Inhalant”[Title/Abstract] OR “Nicotine Nasal Spray”[Title/Abstract] OR “Nicotine Lozenge”[Title/Abstract] OR “nicotine patch”[Title/Abstract] OR “Quit* Smoking”[Title/Abstract] OR “Stop* Smoking”[Title/Abstract]

 

Search using MeSH Subject Headings

"Smoking Cessation/methods"[Mesh] OR “Tobacco Use Cessation”[Mesh] OR "Tobacco Use Cessation Products"[Mesh]

Tutorial: Introduction: What is MeSH?

Databases

Building the Search: Systematic Reviews  Tutorial for searching for systematic reviews in PubMed

  • Putting Evidence Into Practice by the Oncology Nurses Society ONS PEP resources are designed to provide evidence-based interventions for patient care and teaching. PEP topic teams of nurse scientists, advanced practice nurses, and staff nurses summarize and synthesize the available evidence in PEP topic areas. Topics are patient-centered outcomes, such as symptoms, that are selected by survey of ONS members and determination of availability of evidence in the topic.

Manage Citations

Zotero is a free citation management system developed at Mason, and now used internationally.  Advantages to using Zotero for a systematic review:

  • Duplicate removal
  • Abstracts present for title/abstract review
  • Format in any citation style

Tutorials and Workshops are offered by University Libraries.

VIDEO: Zotero in Systematic Reviews https://youtu.be/34zrO3fMYBU

Steps for downloading and exporting/importing large sets into Zotero:

In Medline or CINAHL (EBSCO)

  1. Increase citations per page under Page Options to 50
  2. Select Share, Add Results to folder
  3. Open Folder and Select all
  4. Choose Export from right column
  5. Export in RIS format and save file
  6. Open Zotero, Choose File/Import
  7. Go to next page (if more than 50 citations) in Ebsco; repeat steps until all citations are saved in folder and imported into Zotero

In Web of Science

  1. Choose Save to Other File Formats
  2. Click on Records and put number of records to download
  3. Under File Format, choose Bibtex
  4. Select Send and save file
  5. Open Zotero, Choose File/Import

In PubMed.gov

  1. Click on "Send to" at top right
  2. Choose Citation Manager
  3. Enter total number of records to download
  4. Save file as .nbib
  5. Open Zotero. Choose File/Import